Oil and gas production has doubled in some parts of the United States in the last two years, and scientists can use satellites to see impacts of that trend: a significant increase in the release of the lung-irritating air pollutant nitrogen dioxide, for example, and a more-than-doubling of the amount of gas flared into the atmosphere. 

“We see the industry’s growing impact from space,” said  CIRES scientist Barbara Dix, lead author of the new assessment published in the AGU journal Geophysical Research Letters. “We really are at the point where we can use satellite data to give feedback to companies and regulators, and see if they are successful in regulating emissions.”  

Dix and a team of US and Dutch researchers set out to see if a suite of satellite-based instruments could help scientists understand more about nitrogen oxides pollution (including nitrogen dioxide) coming from engines in U.S. oil and gas fields. Combustion engines produce nitrogen oxides, which is a respiratory irritant and can lead to the formation of other types of harmful air pollutants, such as ground-level ozone. 

On oil and gas drilling and production sites, there may be several small and large combustion engines, drilling, compressing gas, separating liquids and gases, and moving gas and oil through pipes and storage containers, said co-author Joost de Gouw, a CIRES Fellow and chemistry professor at CU Boulder. The emissions of those engines are not controlled. “Cars have catalytic converters, big industrial stacks may have emissions reduction equipment...” de Gouw said. “Not so with these engines.” 

Conventional “inventories” meant to account for nitrogen oxides pollution from oil and gas sites are often very uncertain, underestimating or overestimating the pollutants, de Gouw said. And there are few sustained measurements of nitrogen oxides in many of the rural areas where oil and gas development often takes place, Dix said.

So she, de Gouw and their colleagues turned to nitrogen dioxide data from the Ozone Monitoring Instrument (OMI) on board a NASA satellite and the Tropospheric Monitoring Instrument (TropOMI) on a European Space Agency satellite. They also looked at gas flaring data from an instrument on the NOAA/NASA Suomi satellite system. 

Between 2007 and 2019, across much of the United States, nitrogen dioxide pollution levels dropped because of cleaner cars and power plants, the team found, confirming findings reported previously. The clean air trend in satellite data was most obvious in urban areas of California, Washington and Oregon and in the eastern half of the continental United States. “We’ve cleaned up our act a lot,” Dix said. 

However, several areas stuck out with increased emissions of nitrogen dioxide: The Permian, Bakken and Eagle Ford oil and gas basins, in Texas and New Mexico, North Dakota, and Texas, respectively. 

In those areas, the scientists used a type of time-series analysis to figure out where the pollutant was coming from: Drilling of new wells vs. longer-term production. They could do this kind of analysis because drilling activity swings up and down quickly in response to market forces while production changes far more slowly (once a well is drilled, it may produce oil and natural gas for years or even decades).

Before a downturn in drilling in 2015, drilling generated about 80 percent of nitrogen dioxide from oil and gas sites, the team reported. After 2015, drilling and production produced roughly equal amounts of the pollutant. Flaring is estimated to contribute up to 10 percent in both time frames.

The researchers also developed a new oil and gas emissions inventory, using data on fuel use by the industry, the location of drilling rigs, and well-level production data. The inventory confirmed the satellite trends, said co-author Brian McDonald, a CIRES scientist working in NOAA’s Chemical Sciences Laboratory, “It is a promising development that what we observe from space can be explained by expected trends in emissions from the oil and gas industry.” 

“Scientifically, this is especially important: we can do source attribution by satellite,” de Gouw said. “We need to know the important sources to address these emissions in the most cost-efficient manner.”

Authors of “Nitrogen Oxide Emissions from U.S. Oil and Gas Production: Recent Trends and Source Attribution” published in Geophysical Research Letters January 15, 2020 are: Barbara Dix (CIRES and CU Boulder), Joep de Bruin, and Esther Roosenbrand  (CIRES and Technical University of Delft, the Netherlands), Tim Vlemmix (Royal Netherlands Meteorological Institute, the Netherlands), Colby Francoeur (CIRES and NOAA), Alan Gorchov-Negron (University of Michigan), Brian McDonald (CIRES and NOAA), Mikhail Zhizhin (CIRES, NOAA and Colorado School of Mines), Christopher Elvidge (Colorado School of Mines), Pepijn Veefkind and Pieternel Levelt (University of Delft and Royal Netherlands Meteorological Institute), and Joost de Gouw (CIRES and CU Boulder). The following helped fund the work: The Netherlands Space Office, Rocky Mountain Institute, NASA (ACMAP award # 80NSSC19K0979), NOAA Climate Program Office (through award # #NA14OAR4310137) and the Department of Energy Atmospheric Radiation Measurement user facility.